The Writers Of "And Just Like That" Said They "Never Intended" For Aidan To Appear In The Show As They Dragged John Corbett For Lying About His Involvement

Carrie’s “one that got away” is still very much “away.”

Who would be appearing in the Sex and the City revival And Just Like That was a hot topic of discussion as soon as production was confirmed last year.

James Devaney / GC Images

Kim Cattrall reprising her role of Samantha Jones was a certain no-go given the actor’s long-running feud with her former castmates, namely Sarah Jessica Parker, which had come to a head in recent years.

James Devaney / WireImage

Then it was originally reported that Chris Noth wouldn’t be appearing as Mr. Big. However, he ended up changing his mind and agreed to come back for the first episode, where his character was promptly (spoiler alert) killed off.

James Devaney / GC Images

Finally, production suffered tragedy in September 2021 when Willie Garson, who played Stanford Blatch, died from pancreatic cancer. Stanford’s storyline had to be completely rewritten after the beloved actor became too sick to work, but he’d filmed enough to feature in the show’s first three episodes.

James Devaney / GC Images

Amid the constant stream of last-minute changes, there was one iconic character that fans thought they could bank on making a cameo after the actor actively confirmed his involvement in the series.

Gregg Deguire / FilmMagic

John Corbett, who played Big’s romantic rival Aidan Shaw in the franchise, left many fans hoping for a long-awaited reunion when he said that Aidan would appear on the show.

Getty Images

First introduced in Season 3, Aidan was last seen in 2010’s second Sex and the City movie, where now-married Carrie ran into her former lover in an Abu Dhabi market and accepted his offer to go out for dinner.

Warner Bros.

In a controversial move that divided fans at the time, the two characters then shared a kiss. Carrie confessed all to Big in a phone call, and it ended up being the catalyst that forced Big to prioritize their marriage, and he and Carrie were able to move past the indiscretion and stay together.

Warner Bros.

Last April, John sparked excitement when he told Page Six that he would be “doing the show,” adding that Aidan would appear in “quite a few episodes,” prompting speculation that Carrie could find herself in a love triangle once again.

HBO Max

But when And Just Like That’s season finale premiered on Thursday with no sight, or even a mention, of Carrie’s one that got away, confused viewers were left with no doubt that they’d been hoodwinked.

James Devaney / GC Images

The show’s writers have now dragged John for lying to the show’s devoted fans, admitting that they “never intended” for Aidan to appear and that the actor should be apologizing for the letdown.

Matt Winkelmeyer / Getty Images

Writer Julie Rottenberg and executive producer Michael Patrick King both addressed the confusion in an interview with Deadline.

Patrick Mcmullan / Patrick McMullan via Getty Images

“John Corbett should be writing personal apology notes,” Rottenberg said. “We didn’t say anything.”

D Dipasupil / FilmMagic

When asked if Carrie and Aidan were considered “old news,” Michael appeared to leave the door open for Aidan to feature in future seasons as he explained that Carrie already had “a lot” going on in these 10 episodes.

Jeff Kravitz / FilmMagic, Inc

“There’s nothing old news about Sarah Jessica Parker and John Corbett as actors and beings and interests,” Michael said. “The fact of the matter is, we never said anything about Aidan, just like we never said, Steve and Carrie are getting together.”

HBO Max

“We always try to be very restrained and look at the reality of what people are experiencing and it has nothing to do with Aidan coming or not coming. It really just felt like this was a lot for Carrie,” he added. “This season was a lot. We wanted to get her through this and into the light — the last episode is called ‘Seeing the Light.’ We wanted to get her out.”

James Devaney / GC Images

“[Aidan’s return] is a big storyline that everybody at home wrote that we had never intended,” Michael concluded, without ruling out the storyline for future episodes.

HBO Max

HBO Max has yet to announce if And Just Like That will be renewed for a second season, but there have been plenty of hints that this will happen.

James Devaney / GC Images

Sarah Jessica was one person to share her hope that the revival will keep going, telling Variety: “Michael and I spoke two weeks ago, and said: ‘OK, when are we going to talk about this?’ Because there’s a calendar and you don’t want to let too much time pass. There feels like there’s momentum.”

Jason Howard / GC Images

And HBO content chief Casey Bloys previously hinted that this is a possibility, saying: “In terms of viewership, it’s been phenomenal. I couldn’t be happier with how it’s doing in terms of reception.”

Jose Perez / GC Images

While there is every chance that Aidan could finally make his much-anticipated return to our screens if the series is renewed, the same can’t be said for PR guru Samantha Jones.

James Devaney / WireImage

Kim Cattrall, who played the fourth lead character in all six seasons of Sex and the City and both movies, has spoken at length about how she has put the character to bed for good – and also publicly criticized Sarah Jessica.

Bryan Bedder / Getty Images

In a new interview, Sarah Jessica confessed that she wouldn’t be OK with welcoming Kim back to the show considering how much she has openly discussed their long-running feud.

Dimitrios Kambouris / Getty Images

“If some miracle were to happen" and Kim wanted to play Samantha again, Variety asked SJP, would she be OK with that?

Tom Kingston / WireImage

“I don’t think I would, because I think there’s just too much public history of feelings on her part that she’s shared,” Sarah Jessica said. “I haven’t participated in or read articles, although people are inclined to let me know.”

Gotham / GC Images

Although Samantha has not appeared onscreen, she has remained a prominent part of the And Just Like That storyline and been referenced several times, unlike Aidan.

HBO Max

Sarah Jessica praised the way that Samantha’s absence was handled by the writing team, which included text messages, her sending flowers, and even an off-camera meetup.

HBO Max

“There’s a very distinct line between Samantha and Kim,” Sarah Jessica said. “Samantha’s not gone. Samantha’s present, and I think was handled with such respect and elegance. She wasn’t villainized. She was a human being who had feelings about a relationship, so I think we found a way to address it which was necessary and important for people that loved her.”

HBO Max

The actor’s comments came after Michael Patrick King said that the door isn’t open for Kim to join the revival in the future.

James Devaney / WireImage

He suggested that Kim’s comments about the show and Sarah Jessica are what sealed Samantha’s fate, adding: “There was no thought that Kim would ever participate in And Just Like That, because she’s said what she had said.”

Kmazur / WireImage

“The only place I participate in magical thinking is in fiction. You take people at their word, and you’re a smart producer — you don’t back yourself into a corner,” Michael said. “Magically thinking, it’s great to have Samantha. I have no realistic expectation of Kim Cattrall ever appearing again.”

HBO Max

Meanwhile, Michael recently took the time to share details about Stanford’s original storyline before Willie had to stop filming.

Gotham / GC Images

Stanford appeared in the first three episodes of the revival, but in the fourth, it was revealed that he’d suddenly filed for divorce from his husband Anthony and jetted to Japan.

NBC Newswire / NBC Newswire / NBCUniversal via Getty Images

Discussing the original plan for Stanford, Michael explained: “He was in all 10 episodes. Before I knew that Willie was sick and couldn’t complete it, Stanford was going to have a midlife crisis.”

Marcel Thomas / FilmMagic

The showrunner added that Stanford and Anthony would have “probably” ended their marriage either way, but both characters would have remained on the show.

HBO Max

Acknowledging the fleeting way that Stanford’s departure was addressed, Michael confessed: “It’s the most threadbare writing I’ve ever done just to move him along without much maneuvering, because it was just so sad. There was no way I could write myself out of that in any charming, cute way.”

HBO Max

With Stanford, Samantha, and Big gone, Aidan appearing in the next season of And Just Like That could well be exactly what the show needs.

FINCEN FILES

THE INVESTIGATION THAT CHANGED THE BANKING INDUSTRY

A BuzzFeed News investigation, in partnership with the International Consortium of Investigative Journalists, based on thousands of documents the government didn't want you to see.

READ NOW