BuzzFeed News

Reporting To You

People Accused USA Today Of Fat-Shaming After It Encouraged Taking And Posting Photos Of Plane Passengers

“If you can, discreetly take pictures ... If the airline doesn’t respond appropriately, post your pictures on social media.”

Posted on November 21, 2018, at 5:19 p.m. ET

USA Today / Via usatoday.com

A recent video published on USA Today’s travel section called “What to do when someone invades your personal space on a plane,” and which has since been replaced with an edited version, has been criticized for seemingly encouraging the public shaming of overweight plane passengers.

The video detailed a number of “options” the consumer could exercise “when someone infringes on your personal space” on a flight.

The last of the “options” USA Today listed in the original video was to “discreetly take pictures” of the passenger and to include them in the complaint to the airline.

It then suggested that if the airline is unresponsive to your complaints, to then “post your pictures on social media.”

USA Today / Via usatoday.com

Other tips were to fly at a later time and to buy a $39 “partition” for your seat.

A blogger who goes by the alias Your Fat Friend tweeted about the advice to secretly photograph and publicly share these photos of passengers, calling it “encouraging” of fat-shaming culture.

“Why are you encouraging thin passengers to ‘discreetly take pictures’ of fat passengers?” she tweeted, tagging the outlet.

She then continued in a thread explaining why “discreet photos” cause harm and harassment for the subjects of those photos.

“Did you consider the ways in which those ‘discreet pictures’ become punchlines and internet memes? Have you heard from fat people who have found a terrible kind of fame from those photos, being endlessly mocked, harassed & doxxed?”

“Do you know what fat people have to do to prepare to even set foot on a plane? Did you consider making a video to help *us*?” she added.

BuzzFeed News has reached out to @YrFatFriend.

Her tweets have created a wave of backlash on social media. People are calling it an “instance of fat-phobia” and body-shaming.

This @USATODAY vid is seriously messed up. Encourages body shaming and taking pictures of other ppl w/o permission. ABSOLUTELY NOT OK. https://t.co/46Vrr9bBCY

Some are sharing personal fears they have of being photographed in private and discovering photos of themselves online later.

Others who did not identify as being overweight wrote that they can completely understand the anxiety it creates.

“I’ve flown a few times with my medically fragile, disabled daughter. We need extra time to board the plane, and other accommodations,” one user tweeted. “If someone had conplained [sic] or recorded us to publicly shame us it would have been devastating.”

People had called for the publication to remove the video.

“@USATODAY shame on you,” someone tweeted.

USA Today did not immediately respond to BuzzFeed News’ request for comment.

Being photographed while traveling is literally one of my nightmares. Frankly, I'm large enough that sometimes going ANYWHERE in public can be anxiety-inducing. I've had selfies wind up on Reddit for mockery. There is no 'discreet' way to photograph someone fat and put it online.

UPDATE

Since the publication of this post, USA Today appeared to have uploaded a new, shortened version of the video in question that does not include the part about “discreet[ly] taking pictures” of passengers.

ADVERTISEMENT