Saks Fifth Avenue Exposed Personal Info On Tens Of Thousands Of Customers

Email addresses, phone numbers and product codes were made available on publicly accessible pages.

The personal information of tens of thousands of customers of Saks Fifth Avenue has been publicly available in plain text online, BuzzFeed News has learned.

The online shopping site for the brand is maintained by the digital division of its owner, the Canada-based Hudson's Bay Company. Until recently, unencrypted, publicly accessible web pages on the site contained tens of thousands of records for customers who signed up for wait lists to buy products.

The records included email addresses and product codes for the items customers expressed interest in buying; some also contained phone numbers. Each record also included a date and time, and one of a handful of recurring IP addresses.

The pages, which were reviewed by BuzzFeed News in recent days, were taken offline after HBC was contacted for comment on this story. The Saks website also serves logged in customers some pages over unencrypted connections, leaving online shoppers' information vulnerable to hackers while they browse the site on an open Wifi network.

"This is as bad as security gets," said Robert Graham, a cybersecurity expert and owner of Errata Security, to BuzzFeed News. “Everyone is vulnerable.”

"We take this matter seriously," a Hudson Bay Company spokesperson told BuzzFeed News. "We want to reassure our customers that no credit, payment, or password information was ever exposed. The security of our customers is of utmost priority and we are moving quickly and aggressively to resolve the situation, which is limited to a low single-digit percentage of email addresses. We have resolved any issue related to customer phone numbers, which was an even smaller percent."

Here's a redacted screenshot of the kind of information that was publicly available

It is unclear why the information was publicly available online. But a Hudson Bay Company spokesperson told BuzzFeed News it has "teams dedicated to the security of our customers' data and follow industry best practices for information security."

The Canadian retailer is the oldest continually operating business in North America, with roots dating back to a fur trader founded in 1670. The company is currently on the hunt for a major new U.S. department store acquisition, and has been in takeover talks with both Neiman Marcus and Macy's, the New York Times reported last week.

One publicly-accessible page viewed by BuzzFeed News included a number of Gmail, AOL and Hotmail addresses, along with work email accounts from JPMorgan, Charter Communications and government addresses. These were often paired with phone numbers left by the customer.

Graham, the cybersecurity professional who reviewed some of the vulnerabilities after being contacted by BuzzFeed News, said they could expose people to further security headaches.

"Where there's smoke, there’s fire," he said. "There is probably a way to get password information, but you would have to search further."

The online shopping sites also use a mix of secure and non-secure pages, which can pose another vulnerability to shoppers.

On Saks Fifth Avenue’s homepage, a small notification appears in the website bar warning users that the connection is not secure. Even when a shopper is logged into their account, a number of the site's other pages do not require secure browsing, which a user can verify when “https” appears ahead of the URL.

Graham said that this mix of secure and non-secure pages can leave a shopper vulnerable when browsing on an open WiFi network, as are commonly found in coffee shops and other public places.

A hacker using the same wireless network as a Saks online shopper could eavesdrop on their connection in some circumstances, intercepting data that could allow them to login to the system as the customer in the future, making purchases and grabbing personal information.

"The solution is for every webpage to be encrypted, not just the login," said Graham. "They should all be https links."


This article was updated with more information on the data that was made publicly accessible, and the IP address details included in each record.


Personal information for Saks Fifth Avenue customers was made publicly available. An earlier version of this article said the issue also affected Gilt and Lord & Taylor, two other companies also owned by the Hudson's Bay Company.

Skip to footer