Masterson, 46, had faced three counts of rape by force or fear for allegedly sexually assaulting three women at his Hollywood Hills home in 2001 and 2003. Each of the women said that Masterson supplied them with alcohol and that when they became disoriented, he took them upstairs to his bedroom and violently raped them.
Masterson, who is best known for playing Steven Hyde on That '70s Show, had pleaded not guilty to the charges and claimed that he only had consensual sex with the women. He could have faced a maximum sentence of 45 years to life in prison if found guilty.
Jurors said they had voted seven times over the last two days and were unable to reach a consensus on any of the three counts, according to the AP. Only two jurors voted to convict on the first count, four voted for conviction on the second count, and five voted to convict on the third count.
The judge has set a March date for a retrial.
The mistrial comes after two jurors tested positive for COVID-19 earlier this week and were replaced by two alternates, prompting deliberations to restart from scratch. The original jury had announced that they were deadlocked on Nov. 18 after three days of deliberations, but at that point, the judge ordered them to keep working to reach a unanimous decision.
The weekslong trial featured graphic testimony from the three women Masterson was charged with raping and a fourth woman who also accused him of sexual assault, as well as extensive discussion about the Church of Scientology.
Despite attempts by Masterson, a prominent Scientologist, to keep the church out of the trial, the institution and its practices took center stage as the three women, who are all former Scientologists, testified about how church officials allegedly tried to shield the actor from accountability.
One woman, identified during her testimony as J.B., told jurors that she thought Masterson was going to kill her as she described how the actor allegedly smothered her with a pillow and strangled her as he was sexually assaulting her in April 2003. It wasn’t until over a year later that she first reported the incident to the police.
She testified that she didn't go to the police sooner because in the church community "you cannot report another Scientologist in good standing," as she understood Masterson was, to the authorities.
She said she “immediately would be guilty of a high crime” and expelled from the church, meaning that no members could speak or have any contact with her. For J.B., that meant being cut off from her parents, who were also Scientologists and whom she lived with and worked for, and all of her friends.
"My life would be over," she testified.
During closing arguments, Masterson’s attorney Philip Cohen picked apart the women’s statements, highlighting inconsistencies in what they told law enforcement, their family and friends, and their testimony at trial. Cohen suggested that discrepancies raised enough reasonable doubt that what they were telling jurors was not true.
“[Prosecutors] want to win this case so badly that they have ignored right up until that closing argument,” Cohen said. “They have ignored the blatant, obvious, overwhelming contradictions and fabrications that each Jane Doe has given you.”
Meanwhile, Los Angeles County Deputy District Attorney Reinhold Mueller argued that such differences in the women's statements were only natural given the time that has passed, the immense trauma they experienced, and the fact that they had to talk about it on separate occasions with different investigators asking different questions. He also noted that the major details in the women’s stories remained consistent over the years.
"Each time, they got to unearth what's inside of them to bring that trauma out," Mueller said. "They did the best they can to answer the questions we asked them here in court."