BuzzFeed News

Reporting To You

This Guy In A Plaid Shirt Was Removed From Behind Trump At A Rally For Making The Shadiest Facial Expressions

"Every time he said something I disagreed with, I apparently very visibly disagreed," Plaid Shirt Guy told BuzzFeed News.

Last updated on September 7, 2018, at 8:35 p.m. ET

Posted on September 7, 2018, at 10:04 a.m. ET

Trump held a rally in Billings, Montana, on Thursday night with a huge crowd of adoring fans.

Nicholas Kamm / AFP / Getty Images

He talked about Colin Kaepernick, his election win, the border, that New York Times op-ed... It was the Greatest Hits.

Jim Urquhart / AP

While fans cheered and applauded, people on social media quickly noticed one person who seemed...less convinced.

the crowd behind Trump tonight looks like they’ve heard this before

This guy. Right behind Trump. Plaid shirt dude.

Twitter

His name is Tyler Linfesty, 17, and he's a senior at Billings West High School. He found out Thursday morning that he won VIP seating at the rally through a raffle and the chance to take a picture with the president before the rally.

But we're just going to call him Plaid Shirt Guy for now.

You could tell by Plaid Shirt Guy's real-time reactions that he had a few questions for the president.

@eliistender10 Check out green plaid shirt guy behind trump-they moved him and the people with him🤣🤣🤣😂

Trump: We've picked up a lot of support!

Kevin Lamarque / Reuters

Plaid Shirt Guy: Have you??

@DonnaBesneatte @RanttMedia this was one of my favorites ‘we’ve picked up a lot of support’ plaid shirt guy ‘HAVE YOU!??’ https://t.co/omM7i8zwPh

Trump: It's hard, and harder to win the popular vote!

Kevin Lamarque / Reuters

Plaid Shirt Guy: O rly?

Twitter

Trump: It's like the 100-yard dash versus running the mile.

Nicholas Kamm / AFP / Getty Images

Plaid Shirt Guy: Hrm.

Twitter

Linfesty told BuzzFeed News that he reacted how he would have if anyone said what Trump said.

"I tried to take each issue individually. Every time he said something I disagreed with, I apparently very visibly disagreed," Linfesty said. "I was the only person behind him who wasn’t cheering and clapping at everything he said. I wanted to be true to myself."

He remembers responding strongly to Trump's remarks about his tax plan.

"He said it’s making America do better and helping people in the middle class," Linfesty said. "That's false. The benefits only go to the 1%."

But he agreed when Trump said that the Democratic presidential primary had been "stolen" from Bernie Sanders.

"You can see me clapping and visibly agreeing with what he said," Linfesty pointed out.

Obviously, people loved him.

"Marry me," they said!

Plaid shirt guy, marry me. https://t.co/kRoQu8o3lA

One person even saw a 2020 candidate.

#Plaidshirtguy/Yawngirl 2020! https://t.co/kZdDtHbAeZ

"The hero we need."

The hero we need. https://t.co/cdYlW5A5IB

"Not all heroes wear capes. Some wear plaid."

not all heroes wear capes. some wear plaid. https://t.co/G3QxZBffW7

But, then! Suddenly, Plaid Shirt Guy was replaced!

Twitter

Now you see him...

Fox News

...now you don't.

Fox News

Linfesty said that he and his friends were asked to leave by people they believe were Trump staffers.

"I saw this woman from the campaign walking towards me who said, 'I'm going to replace you.' I knew they were kicking me out because I wasn't clapping or cheering enough."

He had no idea he was going viral at that point, though he did know his friends were watching.

He was taken to a room with Secret Service and police before being asked to leave.

It was ruthless.

@dave_in_sa @allanbrauer Jesus it's some hunger games shit up in here.

A couple of other people in the crowd behind Trump were also replaced.

Fox News

Nothing to see here!

Fox News

A bunch of people thought he was asked to leave because he wasn't enthusiastic enough.

Weirdest thing just happened at Trump rally in Montana. The guy in plaid shirt behind Trump must not hv been cheering enough so a woman walked up and asked him to move and She took his spot #inners #maddow #LastWord https://t.co/pTOq2kBwgb

@Acosta and they ousted the #plaidshirtguy because he was clearly not on board

They mourned his departure.

RIP #plaidshirtguy. You brought us joy.

But at the end of the day, Plaid Shirt Guy isn't gone. Plaid Shirt Guy is in all of us.

@PeggyfromIRB @mkwsaw @TallyWhacker76 @TheViewFromLL2 @dave_in_sa @allanbrauer When he mouths “what?” WE ARE ALL PLAID SHIRT GUY 😂

Still, the trolling isn't over yet.

As part of the prize, Linfesty was able to have his picture taken with the president before the rally, which he took as another opportunity to troll the campaign.

He was wearing a pin with a rose on it, the logo of the Democratic Socialists Of America (DSA), while taking the picture, though he hasn't seen the resulting photo. He doesn't think he ever will. He made the pin, he said, by taping a DSA rose he printed himself over a University Of Pennsylvania pin. He also put it on during Trump's speech.

Linfesty said he largely agrees with the politics of the DSA, though he is not an official member. He said he'll be 18 by the midterms but declined to say who he'll vote for, although "it won't be Rosendale or Gianforte."

During the photo op, Linfesty also tried to trick Trump into signing a copy of The Communist Manifesto by wrapping it in a cover from Trump's own book The Art Of The Deal as a joke. He said he also asked Trump to sign a MAGA hat, but the president didn't sign either.

UPDATE

This story has been updated with the identity of Plaid Shirt Guy.

ADVERTISEMENT