Jessica Simpson Called Natalie Portman Out On Twitter For What Appears To Be A Huge Misunderstanding

“As public figures, we both know our image is not totally in our control at all times, and that the industry we work in often tries to define us and box us in.”

Dimitrios Kambouris / Getty Images

Singer Jessica Simpson and actor Natalie Portman have become entangled in a drama which seems to have spawned from a misunderstanding that has blown out of proportion.

Confused? Us too. So let’s try to break it down.

On Tuesday, Portman chatted with USA Today about her role in the upcoming film Vox Lux, which sees the Oscar-winning actor playing a pop star.

In the interview, Portman said she felt “lucky” to have grown up during the legendary pop star Madonna’s prime, because she was “someone who was brazen and disobedient and provocative and trying to mess with people and always changing.”

“I thought it was a great thing to see in a woman growing up,” Portman said.

Portman then brought up the weird standards in the early ’00s when she remembered feeling that women were expected to somehow be both virginal and sexual in the images they projected, citing Simpson as an example.

“I remember being a teenager, and there was Jessica Simpson on the cover of a magazine saying ‘I’m a virgin’ while wearing a bikini, and I was confused,” Portman said.

“Like, I don’t know what this is trying to tell me as a woman, as a girl,” she said.

Portman’s comments didn’t seem to be blasting Simpson, per se, as much as the music industry itself and the message it sends young girls.

Andreas Rentz / Getty Images

Well, Simpson appears to have taken Portman’s comments personally.

On Wednesday, she posted a statement Twitter addressing Portman directly and suggesting the actor was shaming another woman for her choices.

“I was disappointed this morning when I read that I ‘confused’ you by wearing a bikini in a published photo taken of me when I was still a virgin in 1999,” Simpson wrote.

“As public figures, we both know our image is not totally in our control at all times, and that the industry we work in often tries to define us and box us in,” she continued.

Simpson said women should have the power to wear whatever they want and shouldn’t be criticized by other women for their choices.

But many people who responded to Simpson’s tweet said she may have taken Portman’s words out of context.

@JessicaSimpson Natalie was talking about her thoughts when she was 17 years old. This post is entirely unneeded and has taken everything she said out of context.

One person asked Simpson if she’d considered that Portman wasn’t calling her out specifically, but the magazine in which the singer appeared.

@JessicaSimpson Have u considered @natalieportman might not have called u out but the magazine? That it wasn’t u but the media that, actually, caused confusion by not thinking about how headlines in combination w/ specific pictures come across? Could’ve been any example. I think she’s with u.

Another person chimed in to say that both Portman and Simpson are essentially advocates for the same things when it comes to how women are represented in media.

@JessicaSimpson Just read the Natalie Portman article in question and I don’t think @JessicaSimpson understood what the article was about. Seems like both Natalie and Jessica are supporting women. #SameTeam

“Natalie was commenting on the oversexualization of LITERAL teens & the creepy obsession with purity/virginity,” one voice of reason said.

does...........anyone in the world know how words WORK. i'm trying not to....get annoyed by every single pop culture thing but people are really trying it!!!!!!!!!!! natalie was commenting on the oversexualization of LITERAL teens & the creepy obsession with purity/viriginity!

After this story first published, Portman's representatives sent BuzzFeed News a screenshot of the actor's response to Simpson on Instagram.

"Thank you for your words. I completely agree with you that a woman should be allowed to dress however she likes and behave however she likes and not be judged," Portman wrote.

"I only meant to say I was confused — as a girl coming of age in the public eye around the same time — by the media's mixed messages about how girls and women were supposed to behave. I didn't mean to shame you and I'm sorry for any hurt my words may have caused. I have nothing but respect for your talent and your voice that you use to encourage and empower women all over the globe," Portman said.

Representatives for Simpson didn’t immediately respond to a request for comment.

But we’re keen to know what you think. Did Simpson take Portman’s comments out of context? Or did the actor deserve to be called out? Let us know in the comments!


This post has been updated to reflect a statement from Natalie Portman.