So when they put up matching posts on Instagram on Saturday, people were surprised to say the least.
Kristin and Jay posted this photo of themselves alongside an identical caption reading: "The world is full of users. 10 years. Can't break that."
Followers quickly lost their minds over the post, with some questioning whether it was a reference to them getting back together. This suggestion was only bolstered when Kristin's BFF, Justin Anderson, responded to the post with a comment of his own.
However, other fans instantly began speculating that the post and caption were actually a response to comments made by Southern Charm star Madison LeCroy the day before. And this is where you need to buckle up, because it's about to get complicated.
Back in December, Madison's ex, Austen Kroll, was linked to Kristin after they were spotted on a night out together in Nashville. Weeks later, rumors began swirling that Madison was dating Jay after he visited her hometown.
Well, the night before Kristin and Jay posted their matching statements, Madison had hopped onto Instagram herself, and shared a live video where she apparently made several comments about the pair.
According to multiple comments from fans that were also later confirmed by Kristin's friend Justin, Madison poked fun at the way Austen and Kristin had danced together during their night out. She also apparently hinted that Jay was "relieved" to have split from Kristin and made disparaging comments about her parenting choices. At another point in the video, Madison jokingly shouted Jay's name as though he was in the house.