People Thought Merkel Was Shading Trump, But She Actually Got Mistranslated
Basket of difficult translations.
On Saturday, German Chancellor Angela Merkel spoke at the G20 in Hamburg about the Paris climate accord deal.
Last month, President Trump said he would withdraw the US from the deal, the biggest global accord ever signed to cut greenhouse gases and combat climate change.
On Saturday, Merkel confirmed that the other 19 members of the G20 had reaffirmed their commitment to the deal — but she also had some thoughts on Trump's decision to leave the agreement.
Here's how the English translation on CNN and other news channels carried her remarks:
You are familiar with the American position, you know that unfortunately — and I deplore this — the United States of America left the climate agreement or rather said, announced their intention of doing this.
One word, "deplore", particularly captured the public's imagination.
Hmmmm why does it sound familiar?
You know, to just be grossly generalistic, you could put half of Trump's supporters into what I call the basket of deplorables. Right? The racist, sexist, homophobic, xenophobic, Islamaphobic — you name it. And unfortunately there are people like that.
That statement, said by Clinton at a fundraiser in New York City, infuriated many Trump supporters, who saw it as a dismissal of them as terrible people.
Many Trump fans then "reclaimed" the word online, and began calling themselves "deplorables."
So, some assumed that Merkel had chosen to say "deplore" as a shoutout to the "deplorables":
Here's the Guardian:
And the Washington Post:
Sometimes, it was the opening paragraph of the news story, like in this HuffPost story:
Even the CNN chyron got in on the action.
Except, um, it's not what Merkel said.
Here's what she said in her native German:
"Sie wissen, die USA sind bedauerlicherweise aus dem Klimaabkommen ausgetreten – beziehungsweise haben gesagt, dass sie das wollen."
So the word "bedauerlicherweise" is the one that got translated as "deplore" by the translator. Except, it really means "regretfully" or "unfortunately" or "sad to say."
Ja, ja, we know, German is hard
Based on an updated translation from our friends at BuzzFeed Germany, this is what Merkel actually said: "You know that the US, unfortunately, left the climate agreement – or have said, that they want to."
And not, as the G-20 translator said: "You are familiar with the American position, you know that unfortunately, and I deplore this, the United States of America left the climate agreement or rather said, announced their intention of doing this."
A German government official confirmed to Buzzfeed News that the updated translation was correct.
So, Merkel did not say she personally deplored that the US was leaving the Paris deal, she just expressed general regret that it had happened.
So, long story short: translation is tough, particularly when it's being done live and Merkel isn't actually making deplorable jokes.